http://www.poughkeepsiejournal.com/arti ... y=nav|headALBANY — Roughly 1,000 gay-rights advocates rallied at the Capitol Monday, hoping to convince the GOP-controlled Senate this is the year to make same-sex marriage legal in New York.
While the Democrat-led Assembly has passed legislation twice before, the Senate voted it down in 2009, when Senate Democrats had a 32-30 edge over Republicans. No Republicans voted for it, and a number of Democrats were opposed to the bill.
Power in the Senate is 32-30 in favor of the GOP now, but more pressure has been brought to bear this year by Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who has made passing a same-sex marriage bill one of his top three priorities for the remaining weeks of the legislative session, along with a property-tax cap and ethics reform.
"This is not a political issue. This is not about Republicans and Democrats. Marriage equality is an issue of civil rights, a basic issue of civil rights," Lt. Gov. Robert Duffy told people who attended the Empire State Pride Agenda's LGBT Equality and Justice Day.
The lieutenant governor said elected officials have a responsibility not just for what they personally believe in but for all the people they represent, "and we cannot represent all New Yorkers if we are closing the door on something so important."
Scott Reif, a spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos, R-Nassau County, said the GOP has not discussed gay marriage in conference yet. "We plan to do so over the next few weeks and we'll make a decision based on where the numbers are," Reif said.
Jason McGuire, president of New Yorker's Family Foundation, said he remains confident that same-sex marriage will not be made legal in the state. Voting yes would be "political suicide," particularly for Republican senators, who represent most of upstate, he said.
McGuire's foundation, which believes marriage should be between a man and a woman, kicked off a "Mayday for Marriage" RV tour of the state in Elmira on Saturday and will arrive at the Capitol for a May 24 rally.
McGuire is also executive director of New Yorkers for Constitutional Freedoms, an evangelical Christian lobbying group.
Sen. Ruben Diaz, D-Bronx, is opposed to same-sex marriage and voted no on the legislation in 2009. An evangelical Christian minister, he is hosting a "Rally to Protect Marriage" this Sunday in the Bronx.
Ross Levi, executive director of the Empire State Pride Agenda, said members of the LGBT community and their friends and allies, such as the New York Civil Liberties Union, had a simple message to deliver to government officials: "We will not be disrespected by our own government. We will not be second-class citizens here in our own state," he said.
Polls have shown that close to 60 percent of New Yorkers want marriage for same-sex couples, Levi said. There are two more "yes" votes lined up in the Senate than two years ago, and four senators who were against it last time now are uncommitted, he said.
Sen. Tom Duane, D-Manhattan, who is gay, criticized Senate Republicans because none will publicly say whether they support gay marriage. In 2009, some Senate Democrats and every Republican "betrayed" supporters of same-sex marriage, he said.
Monday's rally was not just about gay marriage. A second issue people were lobbying on was the Gender Express Non-Discrimination Act - GENDA - a civil-rights bill for the most vulnerable parts of the gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender community, said M. Dru Levasseur, a Lambda Legal attorney.
"Trans people face severe discrimination, harassment and even violence on a daily basis, from their workplaces to their homes to just walking in the streets," he said.
Supporters of gay marriage and transgender rights from around the state attended Monday's rally.
Angela Maddalone, a Presbyterian pastor from Yorktown Heights, Westchester County, said it's important for people of faith to speak up in favor of same-sex marriage. The language of religion is often used in arguments against gay marriage.
"I believe that this is a human right regardless of what your faith beliefs are," she said.
She is pastor of the Palisades Presbyterian Church in Palisades, Rockland County. It is a More Light congregation, meaning it disagrees with the national church's efforts to restrict lesbian and gay people's participation in church life.
Jennifer Gravitz and her wife, Donna Lemcke, traveled to Albany from Brighton, Monroe County, to participate in the rally and lobbying. They had a meeting scheduled with Sen. Joseph Robach, R-Greece, Monroe County, but they instead met with an aide, Gravitz said.
Robach has been a long-time supporter of civil unions and has said he does not want to change the definition of marriage.
Gravitz, an associate professor at the Rochester Institute of Technology, said she and Lemcke were married seven years ago in Toronto. "We advocate for each other because we want full rights as American citizens and we want to be recognized and supported and acknowledged as equal to heterosexual married folks, including Senator Robach and his wife," she said.
Gravitz, 53, said she was barred from being with Lemcke and a few years ago when Lemcke had a medical emergency. Lemcke walked out of the hospital healthy, "but I'm still haunted by that," Gravitz said.