ksquier89 wrote:
I really cannot believe you are bringing up the civil war. I mean, really? And associating shit talking during games to social issues is about the dumbest thing anyone could do. I say that West Virginia fans fuck their cousins after college football games. This does not mean they actually do it. And I do not think that if the state were to govern itself that there would be cousins banging each other out in the streets. BTW I am south of the Mason-Dixon so your southern bullshit examples can stop.
Your lack of faith in humanity is truely astounding.
You "Cannot believe i'm bringing up the civil war"...really? We're talking about the issues WE FOUGHT A FUCKING WAR FOR....why would I NOT bring that up? This shit has already been decided, I dont know why you think those lessons no longer apply, has basic human nature changed so much that we're just better people now? I dont think so, and i'm not seeing much evidence for that stance from the people around me.
Lets use the recent Listeria outbreak as an example. Without a centralized government to identify the bacterium responsible, track the outbreak and take punitive action against the people responsible...we'd have no reliable food supply. You think we could just leave something like that to the states? Which states? What if multiple states produce the melons in question, who would handle what? How would that even work?
Perhaps i'm misunderstanding your original premise of decentralizing control and letting the states answer these questions, but I just dont see it as a viable alternative to what we have.
And really, my 'lack of faith in humanity is astounding?" People have died because manufacturers in china are willing to game protein assays by putting toxic substances in the food they ship here. They are willing to trade our lives for increased profit. Perhaps your faith in humanity should be the astounding thing here.