CriminallyVu1gar wrote:
I think the percentage of shots that are on net give a better indication of a shooter's skill and accuracy than the number of goals that go in out of shots recorded. The latter is heavily influenced by luck and linemates. The former is not.
I disagree.
You are saying that the numer of shots on net vs. goals made is a better indicator of skill than recorded shots vs. goals made. That's like playing darts and not considering all the darts that missed the dartboard entirely when assessing a players skill.
To tell you the truth, if you're taking shots that completely miss, they are as much an indicator of skill as the ones you get on net and the ones you get in.
You wanna find out who the better shooters are?
Take their first 100 shots.
Who got the most goals?
Who only got a SOG?
Who missed completely?
You also have to consider annoying details like who else is on the ice for the other team, who's in goal, is the guy suffering any nagging injuries, etc.
Also consider, when a goalie sees a great player heading toward him, I'll bet his butthole puckers just a bit more than if it's some rookie in his 3rd game. That goalie adrenaline can work magic on superstars.
So many variables skew certain stats to a point where they're not especially meaningful. My fav stat to hate is +/-, it's often deceptive and tells half a story.