Squanto wrote:
Their biggest problem is the assumption that players are automatically going to be better because they're a year older. That's just not always true.
Derek Roy has been the same player for the last couple seasons. So has Drew Stafford. Expecting that either player is going to be anything substantially different next year is a pipe dream.
Chris Butler was being hailed as a future stalwart of the defense when he was first called up and played so well. Last year he couldn't stay in the lineup ahead of Sekera.
Since the salary cap has been implemented, Darcy has become married to his players. As an organization, they refuse to admit that a player has reached his potential, and won't get much better, or cling to the hope that a player is going to get substantially better based on experience.
They don't need to make crazy moves, or blow it up. They need to be able to admit that they made a mistake with a player and move on, or take upgrades when they're available.
How are you measuring this? By production?
I know Derek has become a better player year after year. He improved his face off percentages, and nobody seemed to notice. He's also learning to be better on the defensive side of the puck. I saw multiple times this season plays where Derek came back and made some diving poke checks and shot blocks to prevent goals or passes that would have lead to great opportunities.
No one who continues to play in this league stays the same player year after year. They're always learning, always adapting.
The only reason people shit on Roy (and I'm not saying that's what you're doing, Squanto... just making a point) is because he isn't Joe Thornton.
Butler had a bad season last year. Call it a sophomore slump. These things happen.
How many years did Campbell flat out suck until he finally reached his potential?
My point is, these guys are professional athletes. Each season, we really won't know what to expect. Some guys will have off years in numbers, some will have great ones.
But in my mind, the surest bet is seeing the guys that struggled the previous year play great hockey the following one.