mechaphil wrote:
fly as hale wrote:
The smart one.
NYIntensity wrote:
I'm fine with losing Miller, bringing in a guy like Biron, who's CAPABLE, and then an all star. An all star goalie can't win you a cup, but sure as shit, a guy like Crosby can be clutch. Sure, we can make the argument that Miller's clutch and has stolen games, but when the team doesn't show up in front of him, he can't exactly take it on his shoulders to go score a goal. As I grow as a hockey fan, I feel as though I'm learning to appreciate the greatness of elite goalies but also, as I take off the homer glasses, realize that a great goalie isn't going to win you a championship. He's a great plan B. A fucking spectacular plan B. But he's still plan B.
Uhh, what makes you think a goalie like Biron is capable of winning a Cup? And what makes you think that losing Miller would mean that we would get an all star player that would get us a Cup? A great goalie isn't going to win you a championship? Where is the proof in that? Is a great goalie going to hurt your chances at a championship? Getting rid of Miller is a stupid idea.
People often cite the New Jersey Devils as the de-facto example of a team using a great goalie to win a championship, but it doesn't hold water. The Sabres had a great goalie in Dom Hasek, but he never won anything outside of individual awards in the NHL. The Devils, yes with Brodeur in net, also had clutch guys like Gomez, Elias, Pandolfo, Madden, Shanahan, Stevens, and a young Scott Niedermayer doing the battling. The Sabres don't have players that compare to those front-line and back-line troops, so leaning on Miller for everything will only 1)wear him out and 2)waste his prime.
If the Sabres can trade Miller for a superstar stud defenseman or a game-changing forward and sign a very, very good goaltender, I think they'd be in better shape. I'm in no way advocating trading Miller this off-season, but if I were GM and a quality trade offer came my way, I wouldn't flick it off my desk with a disapproving grunt like most fans would.
The only way I'd even consider trading Miller would have to be a package like; Chara, Thomas, Savard; or Zetterberg, Howard, Kronwall, Eaves...and even those two trades I still feel like we're losing out.
Look at SJ, great team, pound for pound possibly the most talented roster in the league; but no goalie = no cups.
Another prime example of that, Philly. Now I fell in love with Mike Leighton late in the year, but lets face it, had they had a Ryan Miller in net, Pat Kane would be back in Buffalo beating on cabbies, and not on the tonight show.
Goaltending certainly doesn't win your a Stanley Cup, but it can sure lose you one.