powerplayer wrote:
But if you take the Dominik Hasek years out of Ruff's career, the Sabres have made the playoffs just twice out of 7 seasons. 2 out of 7. And the two non-Hasek playoff seasons were 2005-06 and 2006-07 - the two seasons led by Chris Drury and Daniel Briere.
This statement shows the flawed logic in these types of discussions. They consistently do two things:
1. The credit for the years that the team made the playoffs doesn't go to Ruff. It's given to Hasek/Drury/Briere.
2. Exceptions for certain playoff seasons are made in order to make Ruff's record appear worse.
Both postions inaccurately reflect what Ruff has accomplished. They also completely ignore the circumstances surrounding the bankruptcy and turmoil during those years.
I'm not saying that it's not time for Lindy to go. I can't decide yet. However, I will call out these 'critiques' of Ruff that twist facts to try and fit a point.
I think what the guy is looking for here is a CLEAR example of when Lindy took a lousy team, and coached them into something. This means w/o adding good players(or starting with them). I guess you could site 'the hardest working team in hockey' years, but why aren't they working hard anymore? Seems like those may have just been a bunch of hard working players who didn't need a lot of motivation.