slesh wrote:
Which is the greater good here?
Is it the families of 9/11 victims and the larger portion of terrorized New York City citizens from that day that are Christian?
Or is it the Muslim community, who also lost people on 9/11, albiet in a much smaller number?
Strictly on a constitutional level, its perfectly ok for an Islamic Center to be built at the current proposed site, but things always aren't that simple in life.
When does sensitivity play an appropriate role, and who is to decide the threshold of that line?
Situations such as this are easier to navigate when there is precedence in place, but here, we have none, or do we?
I cannot see how building a Mosque in this building has anything to do with 9/11, but I'm just using the common sense I understand. After all, there are Mosque's all over this nation. But then we come back to the sensitivity issue for the families of victims and some of the survivors themselves.
The question I would be asking is what harm would it do to move the Mosque 5 blocks instead of 2 blocks away, would this not help the healing process?
Just my opinion mind you, but it is the families that should be supporting the building of this center, not fighting it. One of the greatest things about this nation is its ability to take the moral high ground and uphold the values that generations of this nation have upheld (granted, it has erroded significantly in recent history, but it's still one of the noble principles I would like to think exists in our society).
Politics have played a shrewed role in forming a very ill spirited debate on this issue and shame on those who look to capitalize on this subject by utilizing victims families emotions as a tool for a means to their own end. That is not noble, that is disgusting and only further shows myself how the errosion of our values system has degenerated to such an extent.
A very interesting view of just how Polarized this nation is when you view the debate on this subject. Once again, its just my opinion, and I am no one special, but some of our fellow citizens need to take a good, long, look in the mirror.
Who have we become as a nation if we demand certain groups, or labeled groups, aren't given the same due course as we ourselves expect?
Very disturbing indeed.
When do you draw the line at “being sensitive”? 10 years after 9/11? 20 years? When millions of Christians falsely believe that all Muslims are terrorists? When Muslim Americans are expected to apologize for acts that they themselves were also the victims of?
Muslim Americans didn’t have a thing to do with the terrorism so why do they have to be apologetic and “sensitive”? Are we allowed to just blindly hate anyone we feel like since we were bombed by people with brown skin, somehow giving us the right because we’re “victims”? I’m not saying I don’t understand it but I am saying that it makes as much rational sense as a rape victim blaming ALL men for what happened to her.